Cannot close Excel with WIN32OLE

[ukoenig]

Is there anybody who knows,
what i can do to close Excel ?
With the old TAutoOle : oExcel:End() it was ok.
Antonio told me : oExcel := NIL.
It is not working, because in the Filemanager
Excel is still visible and not closed.

Regards U.König

[jacquetph]

With Fivewin and xharbour, just comment your line oxls:end()
You dont need it anymore .
Good luck

[Gale FORd]

I think what you want is

oExcel:quit()
oExcel := nil

[Enrico Maria Giordano]

I think what you want is

oExcel:quit()
oExcel := nil

The last is not needed.

EMG

[Gale FORd]

I thought the same as you, but after helping someone with an Excel problem we found that Excel will still be running even though you cannot see it.

Running the task manager after doing the oExcel:quit() shows that Excel would still be resident until the variable was set to nil.

[ukoenig]

oExcel:Quit()
oExcel := NIL

works fine.
but it creates the worksheet in the background.

I tried to do nothing on the end.
It works also, but with the difference : Excel shows the sheet
and stays open.
I have to close excel with the button ( because I want to check the sheet )
A Test with the Taskmanager shows, that Excel is closed.

Thank you
U. König

[Armando]

What if you try this way

oExcel:WorkBooks:Close()
oExcel:Quit()


Regards

[Enrico Maria Giordano]

I thought the same as you, but after helping someone with an Excel problem we found that Excel will still be running even though you cannot see it.

Running the task manager after doing the oExcel:quit() shows that Excel would still be resident until the variable was set to nil.

This is definitely not true. Please, show a sample to demonstrate the problem.

EMG

[Gale FORd]

I did not believe it either. I will put something together tomorrow.

[Enrico Maria Giordano]

Ok, thank you. I'm pretty curious...

EMG

[Gale FORd]

I went back and looked at my test prg's and I could not find the one in question so I created one. At first it worked like you said and what I thought originally. Then I got to thinking about how this problem came up. Then I recall that the problem showed up when the function was still running or the variable was a static.

Code: Select all  Expand view  RUN

FUNCTION MAIN()
   LOCAL lRunTest := .t.
   LOCAL oExcel, oSheet
   clear screen
   do while lRunTest
      @ 10, 0 say 'Run Excel Test ' get lRunTest picture 'y'
      read
      if lastkey() = 27
         exit
      endif
      if lRunTest
         @ 20, 0
         // This does not work
         // even though you tell excel to quit it is still
         // running until variable gets reset.
         oExcel = CREATEOBJECT( "Excel.Application" )
         oExcel:quit()
         @ 20, 0 say 'Ok now check with Task Manager'
         wait
         // Works if you run in function that releases variable
         // or you release variable yourself
         oExcel := nil
         TestExcel()
         @ 20, 0 clear
         @ 20, 0 say 'Ok now check Task Manager again'
      endif
   enddo
RETURN( nil )

FUNCTION TestExcel()
   LOCAL oExcel, oSheet
   oExcel = CREATEOBJECT( "Excel.Application" )
   oExcel:quit()
RETURN( nil )



[Gale FORd]

I forgot to mention that when you check in the task manager, you have to look under the Processs tab. It is not in the Applications tab.

[Enrico Maria Giordano]

This is perfectly normal as the automatic destructor is called when the variable exits the scope. It's not a problem at all.

EMG

[Gale FORd]

It was a problem for the person I was helping some time ago because he was using a prg wide static variable. The person in this thread mentioned that Excel was still running so without seeing how he was using the variable I wanted to make sure the variable lost the connection with Excel.

Have a great day.

[Enrico Maria Giordano]

Ok, understood.

EMG